00:00
00:00
Joecoustic
Pizza musician

Beesechurger

Joined on 9/13/23

Level:
4
Exp Points:
144 / 180
Exp Rank:
> 100,000
Vote Power:
3.85 votes
Rank:
Civilian
Global Rank:
> 100,000
Blams:
0
Saves:
0
B/P Bonus:
0%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
37

I feel compelled to talk about this

Posted by Joecoustic - October 4th, 2024


I'm what you would define a self taught musician, I never had the ability to fully learn and understand music theory especially when it comes to electronic music, I still struggle with stuff like mixing and mastering to this day.

The only thing I always cared about was making music, whether it was playing the guitar or sitting my ass in front of the computer and put notes on the piano roll, hoping that my creativity would surpass my lack of quality production in the ears of my listeners.

Now, when I uploaded Mechanical Layer on this website and used the md2024 tag I expected to just forget about the whole thing and to not see my name even at the bottom of the list.

But for some reason that didn't happen, just like it didn't happen last year when I got third place in the competition.

The reason I'm making this post is because I'm an emotional dumbass with imposter syndrome, and comments from people saying that the contest was rigged came to my attention.

Look, if you don't like my music, if you have any criticism to give me just give it to me, help me grow as a musician, this is all I have, all I care about in my life at the moment is making music.

I can't remember the last time I ever got first place at anything, my heart was racing this morning when I got the news, I was so happy, so please, don't try to take this away from me with false accusations.

If you have any doubt about the legitimacy of my submission for the contest please reach out to me in the dms, just try to keep it civil.


13

Comments

Saying that it was rigged its kind of similar to saying you're a cheater, and if you have enough self esteem you can consider that a compliment, look at it that way :P

Like, they accuse Krinkels and other judges of rigging the contest? The nerve! Anyway, ignore it. If they have no bravery and arguments to say that in your face, than it's not worth paying attention

That's really what pisses me off, the judges don't need this shit thrown at them and newgrounds has always been a meritocratic community

I really dislike it when people sour events with comments like that, it's discouraging for both participants and event organizers.

One thing to take solace in is that they probably weren't referencing your song directly when they made the comment, there was probably some other specific intent. For example they wrote a review for one of the music entries and said "I like this one", so maybe they were upset to see it didn't place as a winner. Or maybe they thought their entries were just so amazing that they should have placed.

Whatever the case, they likely didn't mean to slight you when they said it, although that's a big lesson about posting on the internet: when you complain about something, you never know the number of people you may be personally attacking.

I understand that and I'm sorry if this looks like I think the world revolves around me, I just thought I had to speak up on the matter being the one that got first place in the event

@Joecoustic I think it's good that you said something, it makes people more aware of the impact their words can have on people!

Judge here!

Disregard that one hater, mang. Savor that W. You earned it.

Congratulations on your win. I came by as an outsider, and honestly people who use "rigged" in an unjust context are normie beta music enjoyers who are just jealous. I understand your anger at those types, but they are little and loud. Ignore those bugs and keep on composing! I'm sure you make some pretty cool stuff. :3

Side note/personal prattle: judging the music was *rough.* Some of our most extensive debates this year came from music and we had to make a lot of tough calls to round out the finalists. We've only got so much space on the podium, and fortunately the vast majority of folks realize that and are good sports about it. A piece not placing doesn't make it any less kickass.

Do we get complaints? Sure. One or two a year, somewhere out in the void. Doesn't discourage us any, and it sure as hell doesn't discourage all of you from continuing to pump out these awesome creations for the world.

Keep it up, pal. At this point I dare say you're on a roll here.

You deserve all the love you got this year; neither you nor the judges deserve any sort of shame over event winnings. It was just one guy being snide, there's nothing for you to worry about.

And you aren't coming off as being overdramatic at all either, I know I'd feel the same way in your shoes.

Enjoy being a MD winner man, you're cemented permanently as one of the few people to win the top spot in MD history. Real happy for you Joe!

i finished combing through your audio and voting on your stuff. be sure to let me know if you still have any songs under 5 votes.

ps: gratz!